Edition of 19 November 2026
Portrait of Cardinal Robert McElroy

Elector

Robert McElroy

American cardinal, Bishop of San Diego, known for his progressive positions on social issues and his calls for greater inclusion in the Church, in line with Pope Francis.

Country
United States
Born
5 February 1954 (72 years)
Created cardinal
by Francis, on 27 August 2022
Status
Elector · Elector until 5 February 2034

Overall position 21/100 · Progressive

Positions on six themes

How are these scores established?
Six-score profile of Robert McElroy Moral doctrine 2/10, Liturgy and tradition 3/10, Socio-political engagement 2/10, Stance on Francis's reforms 1/10, Interreligious dialogue 2/10, Communication and pastoral style 3/10 Doctrine Liturgy Socio-pol. Reforms Dialogue Pastoral 5 10
Robert McElroy College average

Each theme is scored from 0 (very progressive) to 10 (very conservative). The overall score, out of 100, weights the six themes.

  1. Moral doctrine · 25 %

    2/10

    Cardinal McElroy argues for a more inclusive pastoral practice. In a 2023 America essay he held that divorced and remarried Catholics and LGBT Catholics who are earnestly seeking God should not be categorically barred from the Eucharist, and questioned the principle that all sexual sins are objectively mortal. In February 2024 he welcomed the flexibility of Fiducia Supplicans, said a priest may legitimately decline to give such blessings, and attributed part of the U.S. opposition to 'an enduring animus' towards LGBT people.

    Sources (2)
  2. Liturgy and tradition · 20 %

    3/10

    In August 2021, as Bishop of San Diego, McElroy implemented Traditionis Custodes by requiring priests to obtain the bishop's permission to use the 1962 Missal. Two territorial-parish Masses were discontinued 'for now', while the Masses at St. Anne's, a personal parish entrusted to the Fraternity of St. Peter, continued with his permission.

    Sources (1)
  3. Socio-political engagement · 15 %

    2/10

    Cardinal McElroy is publicly engaged on migration, peace and human dignity. In January 2025 he said broad, indiscriminate mass deportations would be incompatible with Catholic teaching while acknowledging that border control is a legitimate aim. At his March 2025 installation he stressed the dignity of the unborn, migrants and the poor, and in April 2026 he called the war with Iran morally illegitimate under just-war principles.

    Sources (3)
  4. Stance on Francis's reforms · 20 %

    1/10

    Pope Francis named McElroy Bishop of San Diego in 2015, created him a cardinal in 2022 and appointed him Archbishop of Washington in January 2025. The Associated Press described him as one of the pope's 'most progressively like-minded allies'. He frequently grounds his positions in Francis's pastoral approach, and in 2026 he has cited the teaching of Pope Leo XIV.

    Sources (2)
  5. Interreligious dialogue · 10 %

    2/10

    In a February 2016 keynote at the first national Catholic-Muslim dialogue in San Diego, then-Bishop McElroy urged Catholics to reject what he called a 'new nativism' of anti-Muslim bigotry, to build friendships with Muslims, and to stand with them on religious liberty. He also called for Catholics and Muslims to work together for the future of Christians, Muslims and Jews in the Middle East.

    Sources (1)
  6. Communication and pastoral style · 10 %

    3/10

    Cardinal McElroy writes and speaks publicly on contested questions, but in a measured register. At his first Washington press conference in January 2025 he spoke largely from prepared remarks in a conciliatory tone, and his installation homily centred on hope, mercy and human dignity.

    Sources (2)

Career

Ecclesiastical offices and appointments, from Wikidata. Dates come from the sources and some may be missing.

  1. 2010 – 2015Titular bishop
  2. 2010 – 2015Auxiliary bishop
  3. 2015 – 2025Roman Catholic Bishop of San Diego
  4. since 2022Cardinal priest
  5. since 2025Roman Catholic Archbishop of Washington
Episcopal consecration
6 July 2010
Consecrators
George Hugh Niederauer, John Charles Wester, John R. Quinn

Official documents

Links to texts published by official sources (Holy See, dioceses, bishops' conferences). The content belongs to its publishers.

References

Similar profiles

The cardinals whose six scores are closest.

From the same country · United States