Edition of 17 November 2026
Portrait of Cardinal Philippe Barbarin

Elector

Philippe Barbarin

French cardinal, Archbishop Emeritus of Lyon, known for his missionary dynamism but whose career has been marked by controversy over the handling of sexual abuse in his diocese.

Country
France
Born
17 October 1950 (76 years)
Created cardinal
by John Paul II, on 21 October 2003
Status
Elector · Elector until 17 October 2030

Overall position 52/100 · Centrist

Positions on six themes

How are these scores established?
Six-score profile of Philippe Barbarin Moral doctrine 7/10, Liturgy and tradition 6/10, Socio-political engagement 4/10, Stance on Francis's reforms 5/10, Interreligious dialogue 2/10, Communication and pastoral style 4/10 Doctrine Liturgy Socio-pol. Reforms Dialogue Pastoral 5 10
Philippe Barbarin College average

Each theme is scored from 0 (very progressive) to 10 (very conservative). The overall score, out of 100, weights the six themes.

  1. Moral doctrine · 25 %

    7/10

    Cardinal Barbarin has been a public opponent of same-sex marriage: in 2015 he commented on the Irish referendum and on the United Protestant Church of France's decision to bless same-sex unions. In 2008 he argued that no one has the right to cause death and that lawmakers should not legislate on euthanasia under the pressure of emotion. He later said he had evolved on the subject while remaining opposed. No statement of his on Fiducia Supplicans has been found.

    Sources (2)
  2. Liturgy and tradition · 20 %

    6/10

    In a 2006 Le Figaro interview, Cardinal Barbarin said the traditional Mass had been authorised in Lyon since 1989 and that he had celebrated it and confirmed young parishioners there. In 2007 he welcomed Summorum Pontificum as an invitation to reconciliation, urging priests to accept requests for the 1962 Missal and traditionalists to recognise the value of Paul VI's Missal. No position on Traditionis Custodes has been found.

    Sources (2)
  3. Socio-political engagement · 15 %

    4/10

    Cardinal Barbarin's most visible social engagement concerns persecuted Christians and displaced people in Iraq: he promoted the twinning of Lyon and Mosul and travelled to Erbil in December 2014, bringing a message from Pope Francis. He told Crux and the Oasis Centre that Christians need help to stay in Iraq, and backed the international military action against ISIS to protect minorities. He has made fewer documented interventions on poverty or ecology.

    Sources (3)
  4. Stance on Francis's reforms · 20 %

    5/10

    Cardinal Barbarin has never publicly criticised Pope Francis. After his first-instance conviction for failing to report abuse, he offered his resignation in March 2019 and the pope declined it, pending the appeal. Following his acquittal on appeal in January 2020 he offered it again, and Francis accepted it on 6 March 2020. In 2014 he carried a message from the pope to Christians in Erbil. His relationship with the pontificate is loyal and unremarkable.

    Sources (3)
  5. Interreligious dialogue · 10 %

    2/10

    Cardinal Barbarin has been deeply engaged in interreligious dialogue. In 2008 he described a joint pilgrimage to Tibhirine with the leader of Lyon's Muslim community and argued for moving from 'tolerance' to 'mutual esteem'. In 2014 he spoke of interfaith meetings among Christians, Jews and Muslims in Lyon, praised the devotion of many Muslims, and proposed mercy as a concept shared by the three monotheistic religions, while condemning violence done in God's name.

    Sources (3)
  6. Communication and pastoral style · 10 %

    4/10

    Cardinal Barbarin has been frequently present in the media, giving interviews to the regional press and international outlets, and publishing a book of dialogue in 2015. His language is direct and classical, with a strong emphasis on mercy, friendship and faith, and some of his remarks have sparked controversy. His style is media-friendly rather than markedly new.

    Sources (2)

Career

Ecclesiastical offices and appointments, from Wikidata. Dates come from the sources and some may be missing.

  1. 1998 – 2002Bishop of Moulins
  2. 2002 – 2020Primate of the Gauls
  3. 2002 – 2020Roman Catholic Archbishop of Lyon
  4. since 2003Cardinal-Priest of Trinité des Monts
Episcopal consecration
1 October 1998
Consecrators
André Quélen, Daniel Labille, Philibert Randriambololona
Languages spoken
French

References

Similar profiles

The cardinals whose six scores are closest.

From the same country · France