Conclavoscope - Cardinal Robert McElroy

Cardinal Profile and Assessment

Next conclave in:
Robert McElroy

Robert McElroy

Very progressive (11/100)
Personal Information
  • Country United States
  • Age 71
  • Birth date 5 February 1954
  • Consistory 27 August 2022
Description

American cardinal, Bishop of San Diego, known for his progressive positions on social issues and his calls for greater inclusion in the Church, in line with Pope Francis.

Theological Profile
criterion tendency
Moral doctrine Very progressive
Liturgy Progressive
Sociopolitical Very progressive
Relationship with Pope Francis Very progressive
Dialogue Very progressive
Communication Very progressive
Overall tendency Very progressive
Detailed Assessment by Criterion
Moral doctrine
Very progressive

Cardinal McElroy advocates for a more inclusive approach to Church teachings on moral issues. He has emphasized the importance of welcoming LGBTQ+ individuals and has questioned the exclusion of divorced and remarried Catholics from the Eucharist. His stance suggests a progressive interpretation of moral doctrine, focusing on conscience and pastoral care over strict adherence to traditional norms.

Sources:
Liturgy and tradition
Progressive

While Cardinal McElroy respects traditional liturgical practices, he supports adaptations that reflect contemporary pastoral needs. His emphasis on synodality and inclusivity indicates a willingness to embrace liturgical reforms that resonate with diverse communities.

Sources:
Sociopolitical engagement
Very progressive

Cardinal McElroy is actively engaged in sociopolitical issues, particularly advocating for the rights of migrants and the marginalized. He has criticized policies that he perceives as unjust, emphasizing the Church's role in promoting social justice and human dignity.

Sources:
Relationship with Pope Francis
Very progressive

Cardinal McElroy is closely aligned with Pope Francis, sharing his vision for a more inclusive and compassionate Church. His appointment as Archbishop of Washington, D.C., reflects the Pope's trust in his leadership and commitment to ecclesial reform.

Sources:
Interreligious dialogue and peripheries
Very progressive

Cardinal McElroy supports interreligious dialogue, emphasizing the importance of understanding and cooperation among different faith traditions. His approach aligns with the Church's commitment to fostering unity and mutual respect.

Sources:
Communication and pastoral style
Very progressive

Known for his pastoral and empathetic communication style, Cardinal McElroy emphasizes listening and dialogue. His leadership reflects a commitment to engaging with diverse perspectives within the Church and society.

Sources:

Similar Cardinals

Other cardinals from United States
96/100
Raymond Leo Burke
Raymond Leo Burke

American cardinal, patron of the Order of Malta, known for his very conservative positions on liturgy and doctrine, and his open opposition to certain orientations of Pope Francis' pontificate.

64/100
Timothy Dolan
Timothy Dolan

American cardinal, Archbishop of New York, known for his media charisma and balanced leadership, combining social commitment and defense of Catholic tradition and moral values.

61/100
James Michael Harvey
James Michael Harvey

American cardinal, Archpriest of the Basilica of Saint Paul Outside the Walls, former Prefect of the Papal Household, known for his conservative positions and administrative experience at the Vatican.

Other cardinals from the same consistory
44/100
Virgílio do Carmo da Silva
Virgílio do Carmo da Silva

East Timor

East Timorese cardinal, Archbishop of Dili, first cardinal from his country, known for his leadership in post-independence reconstruction and his commitment to peace and national reconciliation.

42/100
Peter Ebere Okpaleke
Peter Ebere Okpaleke

Nigeria

Nigerian cardinal, Bishop of Ekwulobia, known for his perseverance in the face of difficulties (having been rejected by his previous diocese) and his pastoral leadership in a context of ethnic tensions.

41/100
Filipe Neri António Sebastião do Rosário Ferrão
Filipe Neri António Sebastião do Rosário Ferrão

India

Indian cardinal, Archbishop of Goa, known for his pastoral approach and maintenance of traditions in a multicultural context.

Cardinals of similar age
78/100
Willem Jacobus Eijk
Willem Jacobus Eijk

Netherlands

age: 71

Papabile

Dutch cardinal, Archbishop of Utrecht, physician and bioethicist, known for his very conservative positions on bioethical and moral issues, and his defense of traditional doctrine.

47/100
Angelo De Donatis
Angelo De Donatis

Italy

age: 71

Italian cardinal, former vicar general of the pope for the diocese of Rome, known for his balance between liturgical tradition and moderate pastoral openness.

16/100
Reinhard Marx
Reinhard Marx

Germany

age: 71

German cardinal, Archbishop of Munich and Freising, known for his progressive positions and influential role in Church reform, particularly during the German synodal path and on economic issues.

Cardinals similar by criterion

Progressive
Jean-Paul Vesco
Jean-Paul Vesco

Algeria

Moral doctrine: 2/10

French cardinal, Archbishop of Algiers, Dominican, known for his commitment to Islamic-Christian dialogue and his open positions on pastoral issues in a minority context.

Progressive
Marcello Semeraro
Marcello Semeraro

Italy

Moral doctrine: 2/10

Italian cardinal, Prefect of the Dicastery for the Causes of Saints, close collaborator of Pope Francis, known for his open pastoral approach and implementation of reforms.

Progressive
Timothy Radcliffe
Timothy Radcliffe

United Kingdom

Moral doctrine: 2/10

British cardinal, Dominican, theologian and writer, known for his progressive vision of the Church, his commitment to dialogue and his accessible intellectual communication.

Progressive
Arthur Roche
Arthur Roche

United Kingdom

Liturgy: 3/10

British cardinal, Prefect of the Dicastery for Divine Worship, known for his balanced approach between respect for liturgical tradition and openness to reforms.

Progressive
Antonio dos Santos Marto
Antonio dos Santos Marto

Portugal

Liturgy: 3/10

Portuguese cardinal known for his pastoral approach and openness to modern issues, while maintaining a balance with tradition.

Progressive
João Braz de Aviz
João Braz de Aviz

Brazil

Liturgy: 3/10

Brazilian cardinal, Prefect of the Dicastery for Institutes of Consecrated Life, known for his balanced approach in reforming religious life and his openness to dialogue.

Moderate
Fernando Filoni
Fernando Filoni

Italy

Sociopolitical: 2/10
Papabile

Italian cardinal, Grand Master of the Order of the Holy Sepulchre, former prefect of the Congregation for the Evangelization of Peoples, known for his missionary and diplomatic experience.

Moderate
Daniel Nicholas DiNardo
Daniel Nicholas DiNardo

United States

Sociopolitical: 2/10

American cardinal, known for his conservative positions on doctrine and liturgy, while seeking unity in a divided ecclesial context.

Moderate
Baselios Cleemis
Baselios Cleemis

India

Sociopolitical: 2/10

Indian cardinal of Syro-Malankara rite, known for his attachment to the Eastern traditions of the Church and his defense of traditional moral doctrine.

Progressive
Ángel Fernández Artime
Ángel Fernández Artime

Spain

Relationship with Pope Francis: 1/10

Spanish cardinal and Major Rector of the Salesians, known for his dynamic pastoral approach and commitment to youth.

Very progressive
Roberto Repole
Roberto Repole

Italy

Relationship with Pope Francis: 1/10

Italian cardinal, Archbishop of Turin, theologian, known for his intellectual and open pastoral approach, in a balance between tradition and reform, close to Pope Francis' vision.

Very progressive
Blase Cupich
Blase Cupich

United States

Relationship with Pope Francis: 1/10

American cardinal considered progressive, close to Pope Francis, known for his open positions on social issues and pursuit of dialogue.

Moderate-conservative
Philippe Barbarin
Philippe Barbarin

France

Dialogue: 2/10

French cardinal, Archbishop Emeritus of Lyon, known for his missionary dynamism but whose career has been marked by controversy over the handling of sexual abuse in his diocese.

Moderate-conservative
John Njue
John Njue

Kenya

Dialogue: 2/10

Kenyan cardinal, Archbishop Emeritus of Nairobi, known for his conservative positions on moral issues and his leadership in the growing African Church.

Moderate-conservative
Dominique Mamberti
Dominique Mamberti

France

Dialogue: 2/10

French cardinal, Prefect of the Supreme Tribunal of the Apostolic Signatura, known for his legal expertise and traditional doctrinal positions.

Moderate-conservative
Dominique Mamberti
Dominique Mamberti

France

Communication: 2/10

French cardinal, Prefect of the Supreme Tribunal of the Apostolic Signatura, known for his legal expertise and traditional doctrinal positions.

Moderate
Fernando Filoni
Fernando Filoni

Italy

Communication: 2/10
Papabile

Italian cardinal, Grand Master of the Order of the Holy Sepulchre, former prefect of the Congregation for the Evangelization of Peoples, known for his missionary and diplomatic experience.

Moderate
Daniel Nicholas DiNardo
Daniel Nicholas DiNardo

United States

Communication: 2/10

American cardinal, known for his conservative positions on doctrine and liturgy, while seeking unity in a divided ecclesial context.