Edition of 21 November 2026
Portrait of Cardinal Joseph Tobin

Elector

Joseph Tobin

American cardinal, Archbishop of Newark, Redemptorist, known for his progressive positions and commitment to the marginalized, close to Pope Francis' pastoral vision.

Country
United States
Born
3 May 1952 (74 years)
Created cardinal
by Francis, on 19 November 2016
Status
Elector · Elector until 3 May 2032

Overall position 30/100 · Progressive

Positions on six themes

How are these scores established?
Six-score profile of Joseph Tobin Moral doctrine 3/10, Liturgy and tradition 5/10, Socio-political engagement 1/10, Stance on Francis's reforms 2/10, Interreligious dialogue 3/10, Communication and pastoral style 4/10 Doctrine Liturgy Socio-pol. Reforms Dialogue Pastoral 5 10
Joseph Tobin College average

Each theme is scored from 0 (very progressive) to 10 (very conservative). The overall score, out of 100, weights the six themes.

  1. Moral doctrine · 25 %

    3/10

    Cardinal Tobin welcomed the declaration Fiducia supplicans in December 2023, distinguishing sacramental blessings from pastoral blessings that may be given to people in same-sex unions, while stating that the Church's teaching on marriage remains unchanged. At the 2023 Synod he spoke of a Church whose doors are open and welcoming, including to LGBTQ Catholics, while proclaiming the fullness of the Gospel truth.

    Sources (2)
  2. Liturgy and tradition · 20 %

    5/10

    Asked at the 2023 Synod about Catholics who love the Traditional Latin Mass and feel excluded, Cardinal Tobin said that feeling left out is part of the signs of the times and not limited to them, and that he did not think they had been banished from the Church. He has not been a prominent voice on liturgical questions.

    Sources (1)
  3. Socio-political engagement · 15 %

    1/10

    Cardinal Tobin is a prominent Catholic voice on migration. In January 2025 he convened more than 35 Catholic, Jewish and Muslim leaders in Newark to oppose mass deportations, outlining encounter, accompaniment, prayer and advocacy. He has also written on Laudato si', linking care for creation to justice for the poor and the vulnerable.

    Sources (2)
  4. Stance on Francis's reforms · 20 %

    2/10

    Created a cardinal by Pope Francis in 2016, Cardinal Tobin has been a public advocate of the Pope's synodal agenda. In 2021 he described synodality as the long game of Francis, and in January 2025 he launched a multi-year synodal pastoral conversion plan in the Archdiocese of Newark following the Synod's final document.

    Sources (3)
  5. Interreligious dialogue · 10 %

    3/10

    Cardinal Tobin is engaged in interreligious dialogue. In December 2025 he took part in a public conversation with a rabbi marking 60 years of Nostra aetate, calling dialogue the only way forward, and in 2025 he worked with Jewish and Muslim leaders on immigration. Drawing on Fratelli tutti, he has written that interfaith dialogue aims at friendship and harmony.

    Sources (2)
  6. Communication and pastoral style · 10 %

    4/10

    Cardinal Tobin communicates in a pastoral and conversational style, through a regular newsletter to the faithful and frequent media interviews. In 2023 he wrote on social media, urging listening and kindness, saying that even when we disagree we should not be disagreeable.

    Sources (2)

Career

Ecclesiastical offices and appointments, from Wikidata. Dates come from the sources and some may be missing.

  1. 1997 – 2009Superior general
  2. 2010 – 2012Titular archbishop
  3. 2010 – 2012Secretary
  4. 2012 – 2016Roman Catholic Archbishop of Indianapolis
  5. since 2016Roman Catholic Archbishop of Newark
  6. since 2016Cardinal priest
Episcopal consecration
2 August 2010
Consecrators
Agostino Vallini, Franc Rode, Tarcisio Bertone
Religious order
Redemptorists

Official documents

Links to texts published by official sources (Holy See, dioceses, bishops' conferences). The content belongs to its publishers.

References

Similar profiles

The cardinals whose six scores are closest.

From the same country · United States