Conclavoscope - Cardinal Stephen Brislin

Cardinal Profile and Assessment

Habemus Papam!
Leo XIV (Robert Francis Prevost)
Pray for the Holy Father
Receive the traditional prayer for the Holy Father by email
We respect your privacy and will never share your email
Stephen Brislin

Stephen Brislin

Papabile
Progressive (33/100)
Personal Information
  • Country South Africa
  • Age 68
  • Birth date 24 September 1956
  • Consistory 30 September 2023
Description

South African cardinal, Archbishop of Cape Town, known for his balanced leadership in post-apartheid South Africa and his pastoral work combining fidelity to doctrine and commitment to social justice.

Theological Profile
Criterion Tendency
Moral doctrine Moderately progressive
Liturgy Moderately progressive
Sociopolitical Moderately progressive
Relationship with Pope Francis Moderately progressive
Dialogue Moderately progressive
Communication Moderately progressive
Overall tendency Progressive
Biography and Election Chances
Background and Functions

Stephen Brislin, born on September 24, 1956, in Welkom, South Africa, is an influential prelate of the South African Catholic Church. Of Scottish and Irish descent, he studied psychology at the University of Cape Town, philosophy at St. John Vianney Seminary in Pretoria, theology at Mill Hill Missionary Institute in London, and obtained a degree from the Catholic University of Louvain. Ordained a priest on November 19, 1983, for the diocese of Kroonstad, he was appointed bishop of the same diocese in 2006, then Archbishop of Cape Town in 2009. He held that position until October 2024, when he was transferred to the Archdiocese of Johannesburg. (Stephen Brislin)

Brislin was president of the Southern African Catholic Bishops' Conference (SACBC) from 2013 to 2019 and president of the Inter-Regional Meeting of Bishops of Southern Africa (IMBISA) from 2012 to 2016. He was created a cardinal by Pope Francis at the consistory of September 30, 2023, receiving the title of Cardinal-Priest of Santa Maria Domenica Mazzarello. He is also a member of the Dicastery for the Causes of Saints since October 2023. (Stephen Brislin)

Analysis of His Election Chances
Strengths and Assets
  • Pastoral and diplomatic experience: Brislin has led two of South Africa's largest archdioceses and played a key role in the synods on the family in 2014 and 2015, where he was elected rapporteur of a working group. He has also participated in diplomatic missions, notably to Palestine. (Stephen Brislin)
  • Proximity to Pope Francis: His appointment as cardinal in 2023 and his transfer to Johannesburg in 2024 testify to the confidence the Pope places in him. (Stephen Brislin)
  • Representative of the Global South: As an African cardinal, he embodies a growing Church and could respond to the desire for a more representative pontificate of the realities of the South.
Weaknesses and Limitations
  • Limited international visibility: Despite his responsibilities, Brislin remains little known outside Southern Africa, which could work against him compared to more high-profile candidates.
  • Limited network within the Curia: Although he is a member of a dicastery, he has not held top positions in Rome, which could limit his influence among cardinal electors.
Ideological Positioning

Brislin is considered a moderate, aligned with Pope Francis's pastoral vision. He supported open approaches during the family synods, while remaining faithful to doctrine. His episcopate is marked by attention to social issues and justice, without adopting radical positions. (Stephen Brislin)

Network and Weight Within the College of Cardinals

As president of the SACBC and IMBISA, Brislin has forged strong ties with the bishops of Southern Africa. His recent elevation to the cardinalate and his appointment to Johannesburg enhance his stature. However, his influence remains primarily regional, and he will have to rely on the support of cardinals who share his pastoral vision to hope to be elected. (Stephen Brislin)

Detailed Assessment by Criterion
Moral doctrine
Moderately progressive

Cardinal Brislin upholds traditional Catholic teachings, particularly on life issues. However, he has shown openness to pastoral flexibility, especially concerning access to sacraments for those in irregular relationships. His nuanced approach reflects a balance between doctrinal fidelity and pastoral sensitivity.

Sources:
Liturgy and tradition
Moderately progressive

Cardinal Brislin respects traditional liturgical practices while embracing adaptations that resonate with local cultures. His leadership in diverse dioceses demonstrates his ability to balance tradition with the pastoral needs of the faithful.

Sources:
Sociopolitical engagement
Moderately progressive

Cardinal Brislin is actively engaged in sociopolitical issues, advocating for social justice and the rights of the marginalized. He emphasizes the Church's role in promoting peace, truth, and justice, particularly in contexts of conflict and inequality.

Sources:
Relationship with Pope Francis
Moderately progressive

Cardinal Brislin is closely aligned with Pope Francis, sharing his vision for a synodal and inclusive Church. His appointment as cardinal reflects the Pope's trust in his leadership and commitment to ecclesial reform.

Sources:
Interreligious dialogue and peripheries
Moderately progressive

Cardinal Brislin supports interreligious dialogue, emphasizing the importance of understanding and cooperation among different faith traditions. His participation in events like the UN World Interfaith Harmony Week underscores his commitment to fostering unity and mutual respect.

Sources:
Communication and pastoral style
Moderately progressive

Known for his pastoral and empathetic communication style, Cardinal Brislin emphasizes listening and dialogue. His leadership reflects a commitment to engaging with diverse perspectives within the Church and society.

Sources:

Similar Cardinals

Other cardinals from South Africa
No similar cardinals found
Other cardinals from the same consistory
60/100
Pierbattista Pizzaballa
Pierbattista Pizzaballa

Israel

Papabile

Italian cardinal, Latin Patriarch of Jerusalem, Franciscan, known for his expertise on the Middle East and his balanced leadership in a context of political and religious tensions.

51/100
Protase Rugambwa
Protase Rugambwa

Tanzania

Tanzanian cardinal, Secretary of the Dicastery for Evangelization, known for his missionary expertise and balanced pastoral vision, combining doctrinal fidelity and cultural adaptation.

45/100
Claudio Gugerotti
Claudio Gugerotti

Italy

Papabile

Italian cardinal, former apostolic nuncio, known for his diplomatic expertise and knowledge of Eastern Churches, combining liturgical tradition and openness to dialogue.

Cardinals of similar age
68/100
Rainer Maria Woelki
Rainer Maria Woelki

Germany

age: 68

German cardinal, Archbishop of Cologne, known for his conservative positions and controversial leadership, particularly in handling sexual abuse and his opposition to certain reforms.

46/100
Fernando Chomalí
Fernando Chomalí

Chile

age: 68

Chilean cardinal, Archbishop of Concepción, known for his conservative doctrinal positions and commitment to rebuilding trust after abuse scandals.

27/100
John Ribat
John Ribat

Papua New Guinea

age: 68

Papuan cardinal, Archbishop of Port Moresby, known for his work on inculturation of the faith and his commitment to environmental issues, with an open pastoral approach.

Cardinals similar by criterion

Progressive
Soane Patita Paini Mafi
Soane Patita Paini Mafi

Tonga

Moral doctrine: 4/10

Tongan cardinal, Bishop of Tonga, first cardinal from his country, known for his pastoral leadership in the Pacific and his attention to environmental issues affecting Pacific islands.

Progressive
Américo Alves Aguiar
Américo Alves Aguiar

Portugal

Moral doctrine: 4/10

Portuguese cardinal recognized for his pastoral dynamism and modern communication, close to Pope Francis' positions on Church openness.

Progressive
Antonio dos Santos Marto
Antonio dos Santos Marto

Portugal

Moral doctrine: 4/10

Portuguese cardinal known for his pastoral approach and openness to modern issues, while maintaining a balance with tradition.

Moderately progressive
Jean-Marc Aveline
Jean-Marc Aveline

France

Liturgy: 4/10
Papabile

French cardinal, Archbishop of Marseille, known for his commitment to interreligious dialogue and his open pastoral approach in a multicultural city.

Progressive
Adalberto Martínez Flores
Adalberto Martínez Flores

Paraguay

Liturgy: 4/10

Paraguayan cardinal known for his pastoral commitment and moderate approach to social issues. The first cardinal in Paraguay's history.

Progressive
Wilton Gregory
Wilton Gregory

United States

Liturgy: 4/10

American cardinal, Archbishop of Washington, first African-American cardinal, known for his leadership in the sexual abuse crisis and his balanced pastoral approach between tradition and openness.

Moderately conservative
Vinko Puljić
Vinko Puljić

Bosnia and Herzegovina

Sociopolitical: 4/10

Bosnian cardinal, Archbishop Emeritus of Sarajevo, known for his leadership during and after the Balkan War, his work for reconciliation and his defense of Catholic rights in the region.

Moderately conservative
Anders Arborelius
Anders Arborelius

Sweden

Sociopolitical: 4/10
Papabile

Swedish cardinal, the first Scandinavian cardinal in history, known for his balanced approach between tradition and openness, and his ecumenical work.

Centrist
Protase Rugambwa
Protase Rugambwa

Tanzania

Sociopolitical: 4/10

Tanzanian cardinal, Secretary of the Dicastery for Evangelization, known for his missionary expertise and balanced pastoral vision, combining doctrinal fidelity and cultural adaptation.

Moderately progressive
Claudio Gugerotti
Claudio Gugerotti

Italy

Relationship with Pope Francis: 4/10
Papabile

Italian cardinal, former apostolic nuncio, known for his diplomatic expertise and knowledge of Eastern Churches, combining liturgical tradition and openness to dialogue.

Moderately progressive
Emil Paul Tscherrig
Emil Paul Tscherrig

Switzerland

Relationship with Pope Francis: 4/10

Swiss cardinal, apostolic nuncio, known for his diplomatic work and balanced approach between tradition and moderate openness.

Moderately progressive
Louis Raphaël I Sako
Louis Raphaël I Sako

Iraq

Relationship with Pope Francis: 4/10

Iraqi cardinal, Patriarch of the Chaldean Catholic Church, known for his leadership in a context of persecution and his commitment to the survival of Christians in the Middle East.

Conservative
Rainer Maria Woelki
Rainer Maria Woelki

Germany

Dialogue: 4/10

German cardinal, Archbishop of Cologne, known for his conservative positions and controversial leadership, particularly in handling sexual abuse and his opposition to certain reforms.

Moderately conservative
Charles Maung Bo
Charles Maung Bo

Myanmar

Dialogue: 4/10
Papabile

Burmese cardinal, the first from his country, known for his commitment to peace and reconciliation, combining respect for tradition and interreligious dialogue.

Moderately conservative
Pierbattista Pizzaballa
Pierbattista Pizzaballa

Israel

Dialogue: 4/10
Papabile

Italian cardinal, Latin Patriarch of Jerusalem, Franciscan, known for his expertise on the Middle East and his balanced leadership in a context of political and religious tensions.

Moderately conservative
Josip Bozanić
Josip Bozanić

Croatia

Communication: 4/10

Croatian cardinal, Archbishop of Zagreb, known for his conservative positions on moral issues and his commitment to traditional values in a post-communist context.

Moderately conservative
Philippe Barbarin
Philippe Barbarin

France

Communication: 4/10

French cardinal, Archbishop Emeritus of Lyon, known for his missionary dynamism but whose career has been marked by controversy over the handling of sexual abuse in his diocese.

Centrist
Angelo De Donatis
Angelo De Donatis

Italy

Communication: 4/10

Italian cardinal, former vicar general of the pope for the diocese of Rome, known for his balance between liturgical tradition and moderate pastoral openness.