Conclavoscope - Cardinal Pierbattista Pizzaballa

Cardinal Profile and Assessment

Next conclave in:
Pierbattista Pizzaballa

Pierbattista Pizzaballa

Papabile
Moderate-conservative (60/100)
Personal Information
  • Country Israel
  • Age 60
  • Birth date 21 April 1965
  • Consistory 30 September 2023
Description

Italian cardinal, Latin Patriarch of Jerusalem, Franciscan, known for his expertise on the Middle East and his balanced leadership in a context of political and religious tensions.

Theological Profile
Criterion Tendency
Moral doctrine Conservative
Liturgy Conservative
Sociopolitical Moderate-conservative
Relationship with Pope Francis Moderate-conservative
Dialogue Moderate-progressive
Communication Progressive
Overall tendency Moderate-conservative
Biography and Election Chances
Career and Functions

Born on April 21, 1965, in Cologno al Serio, near Bergamo in Italy, Pierbattista Pizzaballa is a Franciscan who has dedicated most of his priestly life to the Holy Land. Ordained a priest in 1990 by Cardinal Giacomo Biffi, he joined the Franciscan Custody of the Holy Land in 1999, where he held various positions, including superior of the Convent of Saints Simeon and Anne in Jerusalem. (Pierbattista Pizzaballa)

In 2004, he was elected Custos of the Holy Land, a role he held until 2016. During this period, he distinguished himself through his efforts in interreligious dialogue and his commitment to peace. In 2016, he was appointed apostolic administrator of the Latin Patriarchate of Jerusalem, and then became its patriarch in 2020. He was created cardinal by Pope Francis in September 2023. (Pierbattista Pizzaballa)

Analysis of Election Chances
Strengths and Assets
  • Experience in interreligious dialogue: Pizzaballa has demonstrated a remarkable ability to build bridges between Christian, Jewish, and Muslim communities in the Holy Land. He notably organized a prayer for peace at the Vatican in 2014, bringing together the Israeli and Palestinian presidents. (Papabile of the day: Cardinal Pierbattista Pizzaballa – the bridge ...)
  • Linguistic and cultural skills: Mastering Hebrew and Arabic, he is deeply rooted in the complex reality of the region, which gives him a unique perspective on the global challenges of the Church.
Weaknesses and Limiting Factors
  • Lack of doctrinal clarity: His positioning on certain controversial theological questions remains unclear, which could raise concerns among electors seeking a more defined orientation.
Ideological Positioning

Pizzaballa is perceived as a moderate, avoiding both progressive and conservative extremes. This neutrality could make him acceptable to various currents within the College of Cardinals. (Le nom des cardinaux 'papabile' qui reviennent le plus souvent)

Network and Weight within the College of Cardinals

Although he was created cardinal recently, his reputation as a mediator and his experience as Patriarch of Jerusalem give him a respected stature. His international profile and commitment to peace could appeal to a College of Cardinals wishing to unify the Church around values of dialogue and reconciliation. (Cardinal Pizzaballa's Meteoric Rise to 'Papabile')

Detailed Assessment by Criterion
Moral doctrine
Conservative

Cardinal Pizzaballa upholds traditional Catholic moral teachings, particularly on issues like abortion and same-sex marriage. While he has not made extensive public statements on these topics, his alignment with Church doctrine and lack of advocacy for progressive reforms suggest a conservative stance.

Sources:
Liturgy and tradition
Conservative

Cardinal Pizzaballa supports traditional liturgical practices, including the Latin Mass. His familiarity with and welcoming attitude towards the Traditional Latin Mass indicate a conservative approach to liturgy.

Sources:
Sociopolitical engagement
Moderate-conservative

Cardinal Pizzaballa is actively engaged in sociopolitical issues, particularly concerning peace and justice in the Holy Land. He emphasizes dialogue, human rights, and the Church's role in promoting social cohesion and addressing societal challenges.

Sources:
Relationship with Pope Francis
Moderate-conservative

Cardinal Pizzaballa maintains a collaborative relationship with Pope Francis. Appointed as Latin Patriarch of Jerusalem and later elevated to the cardinalate by Pope Francis, he supports the Pope's initiatives and shares his vision for the Church.

Sources:
Interreligious dialogue and peripheries
Moderate-progressive

Cardinal Pizzaballa is a strong advocate for interreligious dialogue, particularly between Christians, Jews, and Muslims in the Holy Land. He emphasizes the importance of building bridges of understanding to promote peace and resolve conflicts.

Sources:
Communication and pastoral style
Progressive

Cardinal Pizzaballa is known for his effective communication, utilizing pastoral letters, homilies, and public statements to address both religious and societal issues. His leadership reflects a commitment to transparent and compassionate pastoral communication.

Sources:

Similar Cardinals

Other cardinals from Israel
No similar cardinals found
Other cardinals from the same consistory
51/100
Protase Rugambwa
Protase Rugambwa

Tanzania

Tanzanian cardinal, Secretary of the Dicastery for Evangelization, known for his missionary expertise and balanced pastoral vision, combining doctrinal fidelity and cultural adaptation.

45/100
Claudio Gugerotti
Claudio Gugerotti

Italy

Papabile

Italian cardinal, former apostolic nuncio, known for his diplomatic expertise and knowledge of Eastern Churches, combining liturgical tradition and openness to dialogue.

44/100
Emil Paul Tscherrig
Emil Paul Tscherrig

Switzerland

Swiss cardinal, apostolic nuncio, known for his diplomatic work and balanced approach between tradition and moderate openness.

Cardinals of similar age
29/100
Fabio Baggio
Fabio Baggio

Italy

age: 60

Italian cardinal, Scalabrinian, known for his work with migrants and refugees at the Dicastery for Promoting Integral Human Development.

19/100
Augusto Paolo Lojudice
Augusto Paolo Lojudice

Italy

age: 60

Italian cardinal known for his strong social commitment, particularly with Roma people and migrants, and his support for Pope Francis' reforms.

38/100
Dominique Mathieu
Dominique Mathieu

Iran

age: 61

Franciscan cardinal, apostolic administrator of the Archdiocese of Tehran-Isfahan, known for his pastoral work in a context of Catholic minority in Iran.

Cardinals similar by criterion

Conservative
Désiré Tsarahazana
Désiré Tsarahazana

Madagascar

Moral doctrine: 8/10

Malagasy cardinal, known for his traditionalist positions, his attachment to classical liturgy, and his vigorous defense of Catholic moral doctrine.

Moderate-conservative
Charles Maung Bo
Charles Maung Bo

Myanmar

Moral doctrine: 8/10
Papabile

Burmese cardinal, the first from his country, known for his commitment to peace and reconciliation, combining respect for tradition and interreligious dialogue.

Moderate-conservative
James Michael Harvey
James Michael Harvey

United States

Moral doctrine: 8/10

American cardinal, Archpriest of the Basilica of Saint Paul Outside the Walls, former Prefect of the Papal Household, known for his conservative positions and administrative experience at the Vatican.

Conservative
Gerhard Ludwig Müller
Gerhard Ludwig Müller

Germany

Liturgy: 8/10
Papabile

German cardinal, former prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, known for his very conservative positions and vigorous defense of traditional doctrine.

Conservative
Stanisław Ryłko
Stanisław Ryłko

Poland

Liturgy: 8/10

Polish cardinal, Archpriest of the Basilica of Saint Mary Major, known for his conservative positions and experience in lay ministry, in the tradition of John Paul II.

Conservative
Rainer Maria Woelki
Rainer Maria Woelki

Germany

Liturgy: 8/10

German cardinal, Archbishop of Cologne, known for his conservative positions and controversial leadership, particularly in handling sexual abuse and his opposition to certain reforms.

Conservative
Thomas Christopher Collins
Thomas Christopher Collins

Canada

Sociopolitical: 6/10

Canadian cardinal, Archbishop Emeritus of Toronto, known for his conservative positions on issues of moral doctrine and his commitment to defending religious freedom.

Moderate-conservative
Timothy Dolan
Timothy Dolan

United States

Sociopolitical: 6/10

American cardinal, Archbishop of New York, known for his media charisma and balanced leadership, combining social commitment and defense of Catholic tradition and moral values.

Moderate-progressive
Kurt Koch
Kurt Koch

Switzerland

Sociopolitical: 6/10
Papabile

Swiss cardinal, president of the Dicastery for Promoting Christian Unity, known for his theological expertise and ecumenical commitment, with a moderately conservative doctrinal position.

Conservative
Thomas Christopher Collins
Thomas Christopher Collins

Canada

Relationship with Pope Francis: 6/10

Canadian cardinal, Archbishop Emeritus of Toronto, known for his conservative positions on issues of moral doctrine and his commitment to defending religious freedom.

Moderate-conservative
Péter Erdő
Péter Erdő

Hungary

Relationship with Pope Francis: 6/10
Papabile

Hungarian cardinal, Archbishop of Esztergom-Budapest, renowned canonist, known for his conservative doctrinal positions and his influential role in the Church of Central Europe.

Moderate-conservative
Timothy Dolan
Timothy Dolan

United States

Relationship with Pope Francis: 6/10

American cardinal, Archbishop of New York, known for his media charisma and balanced leadership, combining social commitment and defense of Catholic tradition and moral values.

Conservative
Rainer Maria Woelki
Rainer Maria Woelki

Germany

Dialogue: 4/10

German cardinal, Archbishop of Cologne, known for his conservative positions and controversial leadership, particularly in handling sexual abuse and his opposition to certain reforms.

Moderate-conservative
Charles Maung Bo
Charles Maung Bo

Myanmar

Dialogue: 4/10
Papabile

Burmese cardinal, the first from his country, known for his commitment to peace and reconciliation, combining respect for tradition and interreligious dialogue.

Moderate
Angelo De Donatis
Angelo De Donatis

Italy

Dialogue: 4/10

Italian cardinal, former vicar general of the pope for the diocese of Rome, known for his balance between liturgical tradition and moderate pastoral openness.

Moderate-conservative
John Njue
John Njue

Kenya

Communication: 3/10

Kenyan cardinal, Archbishop Emeritus of Nairobi, known for his conservative positions on moral issues and his leadership in the growing African Church.

Moderate-conservative
Giuseppe Betori
Giuseppe Betori

Italy

Communication: 3/10

Italian cardinal, Archbishop of Florence, known for his conservative doctrinal positions and intellectual work, while remaining engaged in pastoral dialogue.

Moderate
Baselios Cleemis
Baselios Cleemis

India

Communication: 3/10

Indian cardinal of Syro-Malankara rite, known for his attachment to the Eastern traditions of the Church and his defense of traditional moral doctrine.