Infallibility, encyclicals, motu proprio: the degrees of authority of the papal magisterium and the place of Magnifica humanitas
Only rare solemn definitions by the pope are held to be infallible. Encyclicals belong to a different register, the authentic magisterium. This is the case of Magnifica humanitas, Leo XIV's first encyclical, devoted to artificial intelligence.

Not every text issued by a pope binds the Catholic Church to the same degree. Church teaching distinguishes three things. First, there are infallible definitions, which are very rare. Next comes what is called the "authentic" magisterium, to which the faithful owe a religious assent, without it being held to be irreformable. Finally, there are acts of governance and pastoral speech. Signed on 15 May 2026 and published on 25 May, Magnifica humanitas, the first encyclical of Leo XIV, belongs to the second category. It is a major document of the ordinary magisterium, explicitly linked to the Church's social doctrine.
Infallibility, a strictly circumscribed prerogative
The First Vatican Council defined papal infallibility in 1870, in the dogmatic constitution Pastor aeternus. It does not cover everything the pope says. It applies when he speaks ex cathedra, as shepherd and teacher of all Christians, and defines for the whole Church a doctrine concerning faith or morals. The sciences, economics and other secular fields are excluded. Father Patrick Flanagan, associate professor of theology at St. John's University, cited by the CNA agency, notes that there is "no official list" of such acts. The two examples most often cited are Marian dogmas: the Immaculate Conception, defined by Pius IX in 1854, and the Assumption, proclaimed by Pius XII in 1950.
The Second Vatican Council took up this teaching in the constitution Lumen gentium (no. 25). There, the pope is said to be infallible "when, as supreme shepherd and teacher of all the faithful," he "proclaims, by a definitive act, a doctrine of faith or morals." The Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith offered a clarification in a doctrinal note of 29 June 1998, signed by Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger. A doctrine may also be taught infallibly by the "ordinary and universal Magisterium," without a solemn definition.
Authentic Magisterium and Its Degrees
Most papal texts do not fall under infallibility. This does not make them optional in the eyes of the Church. Lumen gentium specifies that "religious submission of mind and will must be shown in a special way to the authentic magisterium of the Roman Pontiff, even when he is not speaking ex cathedra". The same passage indicates how to gauge the weight of a text: it is determined by "the character of the documents, or the frequency with which a certain doctrine is proposed, or the manner in which the doctrine is formulated".
The 1998 note distinguishes three categories:
- divinely revealed truths, which call for theological faith;
- truths proposed definitively, which call for "firm and definitive" assent;
- non-definitive teachings, which require "religious submission of will and intellect". The latter admit of "different degrees of adherence".
Encyclicals, Exhortations, Motu Proprio
An encyclical is a letter from the pope addressed first to the bishops, and often also to the faithful and to all people of good will. It deals with a doctrinal, moral or social question and belongs to the ordinary magisterium.
An apostolic exhortation aims to encourage the faithful in the faith. It is not infallible, but it indicates the pope's priorities. It often follows a synod of bishops: Christifideles laici (1988) and Amoris laetitia (2016) are two post-synodal exhortations.
A motu proprio, issued "on his own initiative" by the pope, is used chiefly to amend the law of the Church, to reorganize the Curia or to regulate the liturgy. It normally takes effect upon its publication in the Acta Apostolicae Sedis, the collection of the official acts of the Holy See. The apostolic constitution is among the most solemn acts: it can establish laws and, more rarely, define a dogma.
Speeches and homilies sit lower on this scale. Their weight is assessed according to the criteria of Lumen gentium: the nature of the text, the insistence with which a point is repeated, and the manner of expression.
Magnifica humanitas in this hierarchy
Magnifica humanitas is subtitled "On the Protection of the Human Person in the Age of Artificial Intelligence." It was signed on 15 May 2026, the 135th anniversary of Rerum novarum, the social encyclical of Leo XIII. It was presented on 25 May in the Synod Hall, in the presence of the pope. The speakers included Cardinal Víctor Manuel Fernández, Prefect of the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, and Cardinal Michael Czerny, Prefect of the Dicastery for Promoting Integral Human Development. Cardinal Pietro Parolin, Secretary of State, delivered the concluding remarks.
The text is addressed "to all Catholic faithful, to all Christians, to all men and women of good will." It does not take the form of a solemn definition. It stands in continuity with the social teaching of the popes, from Leo XIII to Francis. The pope writes in it: "To this living tradition, I therefore wish to add my voice." He describes social doctrine as "not a collection of principles and norms to be applied, but a path of communal discernment."
According to the criteria of Lumen gentium and the 1998 note, the encyclical therefore belongs to the authentic magisterium. Catholics owe it religious assent. The Church does not regard it as an irreformable definition. This distinction also explains what the election of a pope entails. The Successor of Peter receives the power to rule solemnly on matters of faith, a prerogative exercised very rarely. But he guides the Church above all through his ordinary magisterium, of which encyclicals are a part.
Sources
- Lettre encyclique du Saint-Père Léon XIV Magnifica Humanitas (15 mai 2026) · Saint-Siège (vatican.va)
- Presentazione della Lettera Enciclica "Magnifica Humanitas" di Papa Leone XIV (25 maggio 2026) · Bureau de presse du Saint-Siège
- Constitution dogmatique sur l'Église Lumen gentium · Saint-Siège (vatican.va)
- Note doctrinale illustrant la formule conclusive de la Professio fidei · Congrégation pour la doctrine de la foi (vatican.va)
- What is 'papal infallibility?' CNA explains an often-misunderstood Church teaching · EWTN News / CNA
- EWTN News explains: Why do popes issue papal documents and what are they? · Catholic World Report / EWTN News