
Elector
Américo Alves Aguiar
Portuguese cardinal recognized for his pastoral dynamism and modern communication, close to Pope Francis' positions on Church openness.
- Country
- Portugal
- Born
- 12 December 1973 (52 years)
- Created cardinal
- by Francis, on 30 September 2023
- Status
- Elector · Elector until 12 December 2053
Overall position 31/100 · Progressive
Positions on six themes
How are these scores established?Each theme is scored from 0 (very progressive) to 10 (very conservative). The overall score, out of 100, weights the six themes.
-
Moral doctrine · 25 %
3/10Cardinal Aguiar has said little in public on abortion or euthanasia. In December 2023 he welcomed the Vatican's declaration on blessings, saying that blessing same-sex couples is only controversial 'when it is generic' and not 'when it has a name and a face', and that a pastor should give the blessing when asked. His approach is pastoral and welcoming, without calls to change Church teaching.
-
Liturgy and tradition · 20 %
5/10No public statement by Cardinal Aguiar on the traditional Latin Mass, Traditionis custodes or liturgical style could be found. His profile is that of a communicator and organizer (World Youth Day Lisbon 2023) rather than a liturgist, so his position on liturgy is best described as unknown.
-
Socio-political engagement · 15 %
3/10Cardinal Aguiar favors direct engagement with society and politics. In December 2024 he attended a Portuguese Communist Party rally in Almada, defending it as a way of staying close to ordinary people, saying he could equally attend right-wing rallies and urging all parties to address citizens' real problems. Before entering the seminary he served as a local councilor for the Socialist Party.
-
Stance on Francis's reforms · 20 %
2/10Cardinal Aguiar owes his rise to Pope Francis, who made him auxiliary bishop of Lisbon in 2019 and, unusually, a cardinal in 2023 after he led World Youth Day Lisbon. He took part in the Synod on Synodality and echoed the Pope's line that 'the synod is not a parliament'. He is regarded as personally close to Francis and supportive of his program.
-
Interreligious dialogue · 10 %
3/10As head of World Youth Day Lisbon 2023, the first WYD to make interreligious dialogue a focal point, Cardinal Aguiar wanted non-Catholics to feel 'at ease and not out of place'. His July 2023 remark that organizers did not want 'to convert the young people to Christ' drew criticism; he later explained that the event should gather Catholics, Muslims, Jews and non-believers in the spirit of Fratelli tutti while offering an encounter with God.
-
Communication and pastoral style · 10 %
2/10Cardinal Aguiar is a trained communicator: he holds a master's degree in communication sciences, led the Portuguese bishops' National Secretariat for Social Communication (2016-2019) and chaired the board of Rádio Renascença. He gives frequent interviews and uses direct, informal language, which has at times caused controversy.
Career
- 2019 – 2023Titular bishop
- 2019 – 2023Auxiliary bishop of Lisbon
- since 2023Roman Catholic Bishop of Setúbal
- since 2023Cardinal priest
- Episcopal consecration
- 1 March 2019
- Consecrators
- Jose Domingo Ulloa Mendieta, Manuel José Macário do Nascimento Clemente, Manuel da Silva Rodrigues Linda
- Languages spoken
- Portuguese





