Conclavoscope - Cardinal Matteo Maria Zuppi

Cardinal Profile and Assessment

Next conclave in:
Matteo Maria Zuppi

Matteo Maria Zuppi

Papabile
Progressive (23/100)
Personal Information
  • Country Italy
  • Age 69
  • Birth date 11 October 1955
  • Consistory 5 October 2019
Description

Italian cardinal, Archbishop of Bologna, president of the Italian Episcopal Conference, known for his social commitment and accessible pastoral style, close to Pope Francis' vision.

Theological Profile
Criterion Tendency
Moral doctrine Progressive
Liturgy Moderate
Sociopolitical Progressive
Relationship with Pope Francis Very progressive
Dialogue Very progressive
Communication Progressive
Overall tendency Progressive
Biography and Election Chances
Career and Functions

Born in Rome on October 11, 1955, Matteo Maria Zuppi is the fifth of six children from a family deeply rooted in the Catholic Church. His father was a journalist at L'Osservatore Romano and his mother was the niece of Cardinal Carlo Confalonieri, former Dean of the College of Cardinals. He was ordained a priest in 1981 after studies in theology at the Pontificia Università Lateranense and in literature at La Sapienza University in Rome.

Zuppi served for 19 years as vicar and then parish priest of the basilica of Santa Maria in Trastevere, a nerve center of the Community of Sant'Egidio, a lay movement engaged in interreligious dialogue and peace mediation. He played a key role in the negotiations leading to the Rome Peace Accords in 1992, ending the civil war in Mozambique.

In 2012, he was appointed auxiliary bishop of Rome by Benedict XVI, then Archbishop of Bologna in 2015 by Pope Francis. The latter created him cardinal in 2019 and appointed him president of the Italian Episcopal Conference in 2022.

In 2023, Pope Francis designated him as a special envoy for peace in Ukraine, a mission that led him to meet with officials in Kyiv, Moscow, and Washington to promote humanitarian solutions and diplomatic dialogue.

Analysis of his election chances
Strengths and assets
  • Diplomatic experience: His role in peace negotiations in Mozambique and his mission in Ukraine demonstrate his skills in mediation and international diplomacy.
  • Proximity to Pope Francis: Zuppi embodies continuity with Francis's pontificate, sharing a pastoral vision centered on the peripheries, inclusion, and social justice.
  • National leadership: As president of the Italian Episcopal Conference, he benefits from a strategic position within the Italian Church, influential in the College of Cardinals.
  • Pastoral profile: His accessible approach and commitment to the marginalized reinforce his image as a pastor close to the people.
Weaknesses and limiting factors
  • Progressive perception: His open positions on issues such as welcoming migrants or pastoral care for LGBT people may raise reluctance among conservative cardinals.
  • Age: At 69, some electors might prefer a younger candidate for a potentially longer pontificate.
  • Association with Sant'Egidio: His proximity to this community, although respected, could be perceived as an external influence on Church governance.
Ideological positioning

Zuppi is considered a progressive cardinal, aligned with Pope Francis's priorities: attention to the poor, interreligious dialogue, integral ecology, and pastoral openness. He supports a synodal and inclusive Church, while respecting doctrinal tradition.

Network and weight within the College of Cardinals

As a major figure in the Italian Church and close to Pope Francis, Zuppi has a solid network among the cardinals appointed by the latter. His influence also extends through his international engagements and his role in diplomatic missions.

Detailed Assessment by Criterion
Moral doctrine
Progressive

Cardinal Zuppi has demonstrated a progressive approach to moral doctrine. He has shown openness to LGBT individuals within the Church, contributing to the Italian translation of Fr. James Martin's 'Building a Bridge', which advocates for greater inclusion of LGBT Catholics. Additionally, he has emphasized the need for a legal system that guarantees protection and welcome for all, reflecting a compassionate stance on contemporary moral issues.

Sources:
Liturgy and tradition
Moderate

Cardinal Zuppi maintains a balanced approach to liturgy and tradition. While he has presided over Vespers for the Traditional Latin Mass pilgrimage, he clarified that his participation should not be interpreted as a specific endorsement of the Tridentine Mass, indicating a respect for tradition without a strong alignment to traditionalist movements.

Sources:
Sociopolitical engagement
Progressive

Cardinal Zuppi is deeply engaged in sociopolitical issues, advocating for the poor, migrants, and marginalized communities. His involvement with the Sant'Egidio Community and his role as Pope Francis's special envoy for peace in Ukraine highlight his commitment to social justice and humanitarian efforts.

Sources:
Relationship with Pope Francis
Very progressive

Cardinal Zuppi is considered a close ally of Pope Francis, sharing his vision for a more inclusive and compassionate Church. His appointment as president of the Italian Episcopal Conference and his role in diplomatic missions reflect a strong alignment with the Pope's pastoral priorities.

Sources:
Interreligious dialogue and peripheries
Very progressive

Cardinal Zuppi actively promotes interreligious dialogue. He has led interfaith prayer services involving Catholic and Muslim communities and has emphasized the importance of building friendships across religious divides, reflecting his commitment to fostering mutual understanding.

Sources:
Communication and pastoral style
Progressive

Known for his approachable and humble demeanor, Cardinal Zuppi emphasizes listening and pastoral care in his communication. His efforts to renew adult faith formation and his engagement with various communities demonstrate a modern and empathetic pastoral style.

Sources:

Similar Cardinals

Other cardinals from Italy
56/100
Giuseppe Betori
Giuseppe Betori

Italian cardinal, Archbishop of Florence, known for his conservative doctrinal positions and intellectual work, while remaining engaged in pastoral dialogue.

55/100
Fernando Filoni
Fernando Filoni
Papabile

Italian cardinal, Grand Master of the Order of the Holy Sepulchre, former prefect of the Congregation for the Evangelization of Peoples, known for his missionary and diplomatic experience.

47/100
Angelo De Donatis
Angelo De Donatis

Italian cardinal, former vicar general of the pope for the diocese of Rome, known for his balance between liturgical tradition and moderate pastoral openness.

Other cardinals from the same consistory
44/100
Fridolin Ambongo Besungu
Fridolin Ambongo Besungu

Democratic Republic of the Congo

Papabile

Congolese cardinal, Archbishop of Kinshasa, known for his commitment to social justice and human rights defense, while maintaining a traditional doctrinal position.

39/100
Juan de la Caridad García Rodríguez
Juan de la Caridad García Rodríguez

Cuba

Cuban cardinal, Archbishop of Havana, known for his balance between respect for local authorities and defense of the Church's mission in a complex political context.

33/100
Álvaro Leonel Ramazzini Imeri
Álvaro Leonel Ramazzini Imeri

Guatemala

Guatemalan cardinal recognized for his work with indigenous communities and commitment to social justice, while maintaining a conservative position on doctrinal issues.

Cardinals of similar age
45/100
Claudio Gugerotti
Claudio Gugerotti

Italy

age: 69

Papabile

Italian cardinal, former apostolic nuncio, known for his diplomatic expertise and knowledge of Eastern Churches, combining liturgical tradition and openness to dialogue.

38/100
Luis Cabrera Herrera
Luis Cabrera Herrera

Ecuador

age: 69

Ecuadorian cardinal, Archbishop of Guayaquil, Franciscan, known for his pastoral work in popular communities and his fidelity to the traditional teachings of the Church.

33/100
Robert Francis Prevost
Robert Francis Prevost

United States

age: 69

American cardinal, Prefect of the Dicastery for Bishops, Augustinian, known for his missionary experience in Latin America and his balanced approach between tradition and openness.

Cardinals similar by criterion

Progressive
Stephen Chow Sau-yan
Stephen Chow Sau-yan

Hong Kong

Moral doctrine: 3/10

Chinese cardinal, Bishop of Hong Kong, Jesuit, known for his prudent diplomatic navigation between Beijing and the Vatican, and his intellectual and open pastoral approach in a complex political context.

Progressive
Ladislav Nemet
Ladislav Nemet

Serbia

Moral doctrine: 3/10

Serbian cardinal, Archbishop of Belgrade, known for his pastoral work in a predominantly Orthodox context and his commitment to ecumenical dialogue in the Balkans.

Progressive
John Atcherley Dew
John Atcherley Dew

New Zealand

Moral doctrine: 3/10

New Zealand cardinal, Archbishop of Wellington, known for his moderate pastoral approach and openness to dialogue, while maintaining balance with traditional teachings.

Moderate
Mario Aurelio Poli
Mario Aurelio Poli

Argentina

Liturgy: 5/10

Argentine cardinal, Archbishop Emeritus of Buenos Aires, successor of Pope Francis in this diocese, known for his discreet profile and balanced administration between tradition and renewal.

Moderate-progressive
Kurt Koch
Kurt Koch

Switzerland

Liturgy: 5/10
Papabile

Swiss cardinal, president of the Dicastery for Promoting Christian Unity, known for his theological expertise and ecumenical commitment, with a moderately conservative doctrinal position.

Moderate-progressive
Manuel do Nascimento Clemente
Manuel do Nascimento Clemente

Portugal

Liturgy: 5/10

Portuguese cardinal, Patriarch Emeritus of Lisbon, known for his balanced leadership and pastoral vision that respects tradition while dialoguing with contemporary society.

Conservative
Rainer Maria Woelki
Rainer Maria Woelki

Germany

Sociopolitical: 3/10

German cardinal, Archbishop of Cologne, known for his conservative positions and controversial leadership, particularly in handling sexual abuse and his opposition to certain reforms.

Moderate-conservative
Josip Bozanić
Josip Bozanić

Croatia

Sociopolitical: 3/10

Croatian cardinal, Archbishop of Zagreb, known for his conservative positions on moral issues and his commitment to traditional values in a post-communist context.

Moderate-conservative
John Njue
John Njue

Kenya

Sociopolitical: 3/10

Kenyan cardinal, Archbishop Emeritus of Nairobi, known for his conservative positions on moral issues and his leadership in the growing African Church.

Moderate-progressive
Pietro Parolin
Pietro Parolin

Italy

Relationship with Pope Francis: 2/10
Papabile

Italian cardinal, Secretary of State of the Holy See, experienced diplomat, known for his moderation and expertise in international relations, while maintaining balance with traditional doctrine.

Moderate-progressive
Luis Cabrera Herrera
Luis Cabrera Herrera

Ecuador

Relationship with Pope Francis: 2/10

Ecuadorian cardinal, Archbishop of Guayaquil, Franciscan, known for his pastoral work in popular communities and his fidelity to the traditional teachings of the Church.

Progressive
Antoine Kambanda
Antoine Kambanda

Rwanda

Relationship with Pope Francis: 2/10

Rwandan cardinal, the first from his country, who lost his family during the genocide, known for his work on national reconciliation and his attachment to traditional doctrine.

Moderate-conservative
Philippe Barbarin
Philippe Barbarin

France

Dialogue: 2/10

French cardinal, Archbishop Emeritus of Lyon, known for his missionary dynamism but whose career has been marked by controversy over the handling of sexual abuse in his diocese.

Moderate-conservative
John Njue
John Njue

Kenya

Dialogue: 2/10

Kenyan cardinal, Archbishop Emeritus of Nairobi, known for his conservative positions on moral issues and his leadership in the growing African Church.

Moderate-conservative
Dominique Mamberti
Dominique Mamberti

France

Dialogue: 2/10

French cardinal, Prefect of the Supreme Tribunal of the Apostolic Signatura, known for his legal expertise and traditional doctrinal positions.

Moderate-conservative
Pierbattista Pizzaballa
Pierbattista Pizzaballa

Israel

Communication: 3/10
Papabile

Italian cardinal, Latin Patriarch of Jerusalem, Franciscan, known for his expertise on the Middle East and his balanced leadership in a context of political and religious tensions.

Moderate-conservative
John Njue
John Njue

Kenya

Communication: 3/10

Kenyan cardinal, Archbishop Emeritus of Nairobi, known for his conservative positions on moral issues and his leadership in the growing African Church.

Moderate-conservative
Giuseppe Betori
Giuseppe Betori

Italy

Communication: 3/10

Italian cardinal, Archbishop of Florence, known for his conservative doctrinal positions and intellectual work, while remaining engaged in pastoral dialogue.