Conclavoscope - Cardinal Daniel Fernando Sturla Berhouet

Cardinal Profile and Assessment

Next conclave in:
Daniel Fernando Sturla Berhouet

Daniel Fernando Sturla Berhouet

Papabile
Moderate-conservative (58/100)
Personal Information
  • Country Uruguay
  • Age 65
  • Birth date 4 July 1959
  • Consistory 14 February 2015
Description

Uruguayan cardinal, Salesian, known for his balanced approach between tradition and renewal, and his commitment to Catholic education.

Theological Profile
Criterion Tendency
Moral doctrine Very conservative
Liturgy Conservative
Sociopolitical Moderate
Relationship with Pope Francis Conservative
Dialogue Moderate-conservative
Communication Moderate-conservative
Overall tendency Moderate-conservative
Biography and Election Chances
Career and Functions

Born on July 4, 1959, in Montevideo (Uruguay), Daniel Fernando Sturla Berhouet is the youngest of five siblings. Orphaned in adolescence, he was deeply influenced by Salesian spirituality, which he discovered at the John XXIII Institute in Montevideo. He entered the Society of St. Francis de Sales (Salesians of Don Bosco) in 1979 and took his religious vows on January 31, 1980. (Daniel Fernando Sturla Berhouet, Daniel Fernando Sturla Berhouet)

After studies in civil law, philosophy, education sciences, and theology, he was ordained a priest on November 21, 1987. He then held various positions of responsibility within the Salesians in Uruguay: master of novices, director of the John XXIII Institute, professor of Church history, and then provincial of the order in 2008. In 2009, he was elected president of the Conference of Religious of Uruguay. (Daniel Fernando Sturla Berhouet)

On December 10, 2011, he was appointed auxiliary bishop of Montevideo by Pope Benedict XVI and received episcopal consecration on March 4, 2012. On February 11, 2014, Pope Francis appointed him metropolitan archbishop of Montevideo. He was created cardinal on February 14, 2015, receiving the title of Cardinal-Priest of Santa Galla. (Daniel Fernando Sturla Berhouet, Daniel Sturla)

Within the Roman Curia, he is a member of several dicasteries, including the Congregation for Institutes of Consecrated Life and Societies of Apostolic Life, the Pontifical Council for the Promotion of the New Evangelization, the Pontifical Commission for Latin America, and the Cardinal Commission of the Administration of the Patrimony of the Apostolic See. (Daniel Fernando Sturla Berhouet)

Analysis of his election chances
Strengths and assets
  • Proximity to Pope Francis: His rapid appointment as archbishop and then cardinal testifies to the trust placed in him by Pope Francis. (Daniel Fernando Sturla Berhouet)
  • Diverse pastoral experience: His career within the Salesians and his episcopal responsibilities give him solid experience in ecclesiastical governance. (Daniel Fernando Sturla Berhouet)
  • Latin American anchoring: Coming from a dynamic region of the Catholic Church, he could represent geographical continuity after Francis's pontificate.
Weaknesses and limiting factors
  • Conservative ideological positioning: Although close to Pope Francis, he is perceived as having conservative positions, particularly on issues such as the blessing of same-sex couples, which could raise concerns among progressive cardinals.
  • Lack of international visibility: Less known on the world stage than other papabili, his profile might not gather sufficient consensus within the College of Cardinals.
Ideological positioning

Cardinal Sturla is generally considered conservative. He has expressed criticism of documents such as Fiducia supplicans, calling it "ambiguous, divisive, and confusing." He is also skeptical about the concept of synodality. (Who Will Be The Next Pope? - BIG C CATHOLICS)

Network and weight within the College of Cardinals

As a member of several Roman dicasteries and an influential figure in Latin America, he has an extensive network. However, his influence within the College of Cardinals remains moderate compared to more prominent figures.

Detailed Assessment by Criterion
Moral doctrine
Very conservative

Cardinal Sturla maintains a firm stance on traditional Catholic moral teachings. He has publicly opposed abortion, expressing hope that it will eventually be recognized as a cruelty and prohibited. Additionally, he has rejected the blessing of same-sex unions, emphasizing adherence to established Church doctrine.

Sources:
Liturgy and tradition
Conservative

As a Salesian, Cardinal Sturla emphasizes the importance of traditional liturgical practices rooted in the Catholic faith. He has been instrumental in promoting the unique liturgical heritage of the Church in Uruguay.

Sources:
Sociopolitical engagement
Moderate

Cardinal Sturla demonstrates a strong commitment to social justice, particularly in serving the poor and marginalized. He has actively engaged in issues related to migration, poverty, and social inclusion, aligning with progressive sociopolitical engagement.

Sources:
Relationship with Pope Francis
Conservative

A close collaborator of Pope Francis, Cardinal Sturla supports the Pope's reforms and vision for a Church that reaches out to all. He has defended Pope Francis against criticisms and aligns with his emphasis on pastoral care and inclusivity.

Sources:
Interreligious dialogue and peripheries
Moderate-conservative

Cardinal Sturla promotes interreligious dialogue, recognizing its importance in a pluralistic society. He encourages engagement with different faith traditions to foster mutual understanding and peace.

Sources:
Communication and pastoral style
Moderate-conservative

Known for his effective communication and pastoral sensitivity, Cardinal Sturla emphasizes the need for the Church to engage with modern culture and technology. He advocates for a Church that listens and speaks in ways that resonate with contemporary society.

Sources:

Similar Cardinals

Other cardinals from Uruguay
No similar cardinals found
Other cardinals from the same consistory
61/100
Charles Maung Bo
Charles Maung Bo

Myanmar

Papabile

Burmese cardinal, the first from his country, known for his commitment to peace and reconciliation, combining respect for tradition and interreligious dialogue.

57/100
Dominique Mamberti
Dominique Mamberti

France

French cardinal, Prefect of the Supreme Tribunal of the Apostolic Signatura, known for his legal expertise and traditional doctrinal positions.

51/100
Berhaneyesus Demerew Souraphiel
Berhaneyesus Demerew Souraphiel

Ethiopia

Ethiopian cardinal of Eastern rite, known for his defense of traditional Church values and his pastoral work in a context of religious tensions.

Cardinals of similar age
51/100
Baselios Cleemis
Baselios Cleemis

India

age: 65

Indian cardinal of Syro-Malankara rite, known for his attachment to the Eastern traditions of the Church and his defense of traditional moral doctrine.

44/100
Fridolin Ambongo Besungu
Fridolin Ambongo Besungu

Democratic Republic of the Congo

age: 65

Papabile

Congolese cardinal, Archbishop of Kinshasa, known for his commitment to social justice and human rights defense, while maintaining a traditional doctrinal position.

32/100
Sérgio da Rocha
Sérgio da Rocha

Brazil

age: 65

Brazilian cardinal, Archbishop of Salvador de Bahia, known for his balanced pastoral leadership and commitment to a more synodal Church closer to existential peripheries.

Cardinals similar by criterion

Conservative
Albert Malcolm Ranjith Patabendige Don
Albert Malcolm Ranjith Patabendige Don

Sri Lanka

Moral doctrine: 9/10
Papabile

Sri Lankan cardinal with strong traditionalist positions, known for his attachment to traditional liturgy and defense of Catholic doctrine.

Conservative
Gerhard Ludwig Müller
Gerhard Ludwig Müller

Germany

Moral doctrine: 9/10
Papabile

German cardinal, former prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, known for his very conservative positions and vigorous defense of traditional doctrine.

Conservative
Stanisław Ryłko
Stanisław Ryłko

Poland

Moral doctrine: 9/10

Polish cardinal, Archpriest of the Basilica of Saint Mary Major, known for his conservative positions and experience in lay ministry, in the tradition of John Paul II.

Conservative
Gerhard Ludwig Müller
Gerhard Ludwig Müller

Germany

Liturgy: 8/10
Papabile

German cardinal, former prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, known for his very conservative positions and vigorous defense of traditional doctrine.

Conservative
Stanisław Ryłko
Stanisław Ryłko

Poland

Liturgy: 8/10

Polish cardinal, Archpriest of the Basilica of Saint Mary Major, known for his conservative positions and experience in lay ministry, in the tradition of John Paul II.

Conservative
Rainer Maria Woelki
Rainer Maria Woelki

Germany

Liturgy: 8/10

German cardinal, Archbishop of Cologne, known for his conservative positions and controversial leadership, particularly in handling sexual abuse and his opposition to certain reforms.

Moderate-conservative
Charles Maung Bo
Charles Maung Bo

Myanmar

Sociopolitical: 5/10
Papabile

Burmese cardinal, the first from his country, known for his commitment to peace and reconciliation, combining respect for tradition and interreligious dialogue.

Moderate-conservative
James Michael Harvey
James Michael Harvey

United States

Sociopolitical: 5/10

American cardinal, Archpriest of the Basilica of Saint Paul Outside the Walls, former Prefect of the Papal Household, known for his conservative positions and administrative experience at the Vatican.

Moderate-conservative
Philippe Barbarin
Philippe Barbarin

France

Sociopolitical: 5/10

French cardinal, Archbishop Emeritus of Lyon, known for his missionary dynamism but whose career has been marked by controversy over the handling of sexual abuse in his diocese.

Moderate-conservative
Charles Maung Bo
Charles Maung Bo

Myanmar

Relationship with Pope Francis: 7/10
Papabile

Burmese cardinal, the first from his country, known for his commitment to peace and reconciliation, combining respect for tradition and interreligious dialogue.

Moderate-conservative
Dominique Mamberti
Dominique Mamberti

France

Relationship with Pope Francis: 7/10

French cardinal, Prefect of the Supreme Tribunal of the Apostolic Signatura, known for his legal expertise and traditional doctrinal positions.

Moderate
Fernando Filoni
Fernando Filoni

Italy

Relationship with Pope Francis: 7/10
Papabile

Italian cardinal, Grand Master of the Order of the Holy Sepulchre, former prefect of the Congregation for the Evangelization of Peoples, known for his missionary and diplomatic experience.

Very conservative
Antonio Cañizares Llovera
Antonio Cañizares Llovera

Spain

Dialogue: 6/10

Spanish cardinal who is very conservative, nicknamed "the little Ratzinger," known for his traditionalist positions on liturgy and morality, and his vigorous defense of Catholic doctrine.

Conservative
Albert Malcolm Ranjith Patabendige Don
Albert Malcolm Ranjith Patabendige Don

Sri Lanka

Dialogue: 6/10
Papabile

Sri Lankan cardinal with strong traditionalist positions, known for his attachment to traditional liturgy and defense of Catholic doctrine.

Conservative
Stanisław Ryłko
Stanisław Ryłko

Poland

Dialogue: 6/10

Polish cardinal, Archpriest of the Basilica of Saint Mary Major, known for his conservative positions and experience in lay ministry, in the tradition of John Paul II.

Conservative
Albert Malcolm Ranjith Patabendige Don
Albert Malcolm Ranjith Patabendige Don

Sri Lanka

Communication: 6/10
Papabile

Sri Lankan cardinal with strong traditionalist positions, known for his attachment to traditional liturgy and defense of Catholic doctrine.

Conservative
Willem Jacobus Eijk
Willem Jacobus Eijk

Netherlands

Communication: 6/10
Papabile

Dutch cardinal, Archbishop of Utrecht, physician and bioethicist, known for his very conservative positions on bioethical and moral issues, and his defense of traditional doctrine.

Conservative
Rainer Maria Woelki
Rainer Maria Woelki

Germany

Communication: 6/10

German cardinal, Archbishop of Cologne, known for his conservative positions and controversial leadership, particularly in handling sexual abuse and his opposition to certain reforms.